Greetings, The Rebel:
Whatever makes one attractive to others -- looks, manner, intellect, talent -- can be boon or bane to the holder. In many a situation, a friendly, outgoing individual may capture the heart of another individual (or, many) and be quite incapable of reciprocating in the measure the starstruck one expects.
Onstage as a performer for many years, I have a little experience with audiences. They can love you but forget you once you're offstage. Or, they may hate you from the start. It's a difficult road to hoe, that of a performer.
It's like the adoring masses who worship a public figure and see only the outside. What would it be like to live with that "beautiful" person?
Anyway, mon ami, that's an aspect of charisma, as I perceive it.
I always enjoy reading you . . .